I Know Who Killed Me Review by Zara (4 Stars) | MatchFlick
Left Header Right Header
Header 3a   Header Right End A Header Right End B Space
Header Left 3b
Movie Reviews Columns Now on DVD Now Playing News
FREE Membership Member Login About MatchFlick  FAQ's MatchFlick Friday
Steal of the Day
Jerry Lewis - The Legendary Jerry Lewis Collection 10-Disc Set DVD
$56.99
$35.99
The Steal of the Day is offered by MatchFlick's DVD partner, FamilyVideo.com.


 

Member Login  [help]
 
 
 
 
 
Membership
 Join for FREE
 FAQs
 About MatchFlick
 Privacy Policy
Popular Movies  [more]
 Fight Club
 Pulp Fiction
 Eternal Sunshine
Popular People  [more]
 Johnny Depp
 Tom Hanks
 Natalie Portman
Member Trends
 Horror Club
 Reviewer Stats
Movie News
 Current News
 News Archives
Message Board
 Go To The Forum
Columns   [more]
 Dr. Karma's Holi...
 Until Watchmen A...
 Will Trick 'r Tr...
 Mutants On Parad...
 COLUMNS ARCHIVES
Contests
 GUESS THAT SCENE
Syndication
 RSS FEEDS
  
MatchFlick Member Reviews
I Know Who Killed Me
6 reviews

review this movie

read all reviews

Movie Details

All Movie Info

Starring:
Lindsay Lohan, Julia Ormond, Neal McDonough, Brian Geraghty, Garcelle Beauvais, Spencer Garrett, Gregory Itzin, Bonnie Aarons, Kenya Moore, Rodney Rowland, Paula Marshall, Eddie Steeples, Brian McNamara, Michael Papajohn, Colleen Porch, Donovan Scott, Shay Astar, Debra Christofferson, Cornelia Guest, David A. Kimball, Michelle Page, Wynter Kullman, Marc Senter, Theo Kypri, Michael Esparza, Megan Henning, Thomas Tofel, David Figlioli, Jessica Rose, Kaitlyn Lee Cruz

Directed By:
Chris Sivertson, Chris Sivertson

Written By:
Jeff Hammond


 
I Know Who Killed Me (2007)
email this review to a friend

Movie Review by Zara
August 3rd, 2007

Read the Review to Understand the Star Rating

This movie left me completely dumbfounded with how to rate it with stars. I am willing to put it right there in the same category as PHENOMENA, a movie that is soooooo f*cking bad that I love it completely. While I don't think that I could bring myself to say that this was PHENOMENA status, I can say that I had more laughs while watching this movie than I did when I went to go see THE SIMPSONS MOVIE.

Here are just a few of the plot points that I found HIGH-larious:

* "I just hope this investigation doesn't cut into Bingo night"

What the f*ck point that comment was towards the beginning of the movie when they were trying to figure out who was mutilating women, cutting off their arms and legs, I don't know. If it was meant to be a joke, it's not said in that manner. If it was meant to be serious, then WHAT THE F*CK?? The guy might as well have started quacking like a duck after he said it. (Just for you, Paul.)

* The bloody finger with the complete lack of regard for the fact that shock should have set in.

This part bugged my sister more than me first. Then it reminded me of Eli Roth's crappy movie HOSTEL (one of those bad in a bad way movies) and how Jay Hernandez is able to make a trip on a train for literally hours with 3 fingers missing and not only refrain from going into shock but have the power within him to kill a man after getting off the train.

In this movie, we get to see Lindsay pout and ask the guy on the bus (and she's smoking on the bus- natch!) why he doesn't ask about her hand, only to hear the next monumental line: "Sometimes people just get cut." (Or something asinine to that general effect.)

* The strip club with the nudity of everyone BUT Lindsay.

I've heard that a lot of horny dudes wanted to go see this movie to watch Linds be a stripper. I'd like to warn you all and let you know that you'll see more of her in a copy of US Weekly when they talk about how she doesn't wear underwear. In a strip club where all the other strippers have their t*ts hanging out, Lindsay is sans nudity. But she writhes around on the floor and bats her heavily made up eyes. And the camera gets in close for some camel toe shots. Whoopie!

* The f*cking of the boyfriend.

Since she keeps insisting that she's not the girl that everyone thinks she is, she decides to f*ck the girl's boyfriend to see if he'll notice the difference. The mom sits downstairs and furiously cleans while listening to their noise. Then she asks if he notices a difference or cares. Um... how about NO? This was just another brilliant bit of stupidity.

* The only child of two working parents... who are always home.

Gotta love how this always happens in movies like this. The parents are workaholics who can't remember what their daughter was wearing when she left the house, making enough money and being important to have all the money that they do and yet they're always home whenever their roles call for it. This isn't just a problem with this movie, this is a typical problem in most movies. (Also think DISTURBIA with the mom who's not only always around but also appears to be completely emotionally OK with her husband's horrific death only a year previous.)

* The piano teacher is the killer.

Sorry if this ruins it for anyone. But frankly... why the f*ck was he the killer? What was the point, the purpose, the motivation? He wanted them to continue to be good musicians... so he'll mutilate and murder them? And what was his obsession with all of the prosthetic legs hanging in the basement? I know it doesn't really matter, stuff like this is so inconsequential these days... but still... WTF??

Oh, and I laughed hysterically when they showed him banging away at the piano with his one working hand. Because, you know... he'd suddenly lose all talent and just bang away like a 4 year old with a noise complex.

* Owl

Yes, I actually said out loud "Thank you owl, you can fly back to Hogwart's now," when she got to that part where the owl leads the way to the burial site.

* No oxygen = the strength enough to dig someone out of a hole.

I thought they were symbiotic... that she was having trouble breathing. Yet she seems to summon the strength to completely dig up the grave of her twin sister and the best that the girl can do after being rescued by someone who is her f*cking doppleganger is smile like a retard?

Oh, and while we're on that topic... how is it that the music teacher was able to afford a stained glass coffin with the blue roses on it, let alone not raise suspicion as to why he would need something like that ordered and delivered to his home? I'm just thinking out loud here people... (as well as talking to the screen in the theater.

* Cuddle Buddies

Really.... that was the best shot to end the film on? F*cking hell....

email this review to a friend

Comment on this Review:

Sorry, you must be a member to add comments to reviews.

Join or Login.



B Movie Ben
Aug 3, 2007 6:40 AM
also wrote a review of I Know Who Killed Me
 
WTF - 4 stars and then you completely tear it to hell, including the spoiler that Lindsey doesn't have her t*ts hanging out along with all the other strippers? You have me confused.
Zara
Aug 3, 2007 9:55 AM
 
Did you not read the first paragraph?

Zombie Boy
Aug 3, 2007 3:01 PM
also wrote a review of I Know Who Killed Me
 
You should really put a spoiler alert at the beginning. Whatever you thought of it is no reason to ruin for someone else. Seriously.

I might do a review myself. I enjoyed it more than you did, but just about all of your points are valid. I think the parents are home more later int he movie because their daughter was kidnapped and brutally disfigured. Kinda makes sense. And the piano teacher was banging away like that not because suddenly he didn't know how to play. but maybe because he was a teensy bit distraught at having his hand cut off.
Zara
Aug 3, 2007 6:22 PM
 
Unlike Fat Boy who posts a link when he runs out of room, I actually edited my piece when it hit the maximum characters.

1) f*ck spoilers. If you don't want the movie ruined for you, don't read any reviews before you see it. That's how I roll.

2) I wanted to add that it was funny when the teacher went walking up to the bowl of ice with the severed hand, one arm looking 2 feet longer than the other (a clear showing that it was bandaged over his regular hand, which was silly only because of the extent that they went to with the special effects for Lindsay's leg and arm) and attempt to stick the hand back ONTO THE BANDAGED WRIST. Very PHENOMENA funny.

3) There is also NO WAY that a chick who was stripping at a high school age would look as clean and healthy as the doppleganger did. She would have had piercings, tattoos and not worn some cutesy crocheted cap. Although I suppose having her realistically look like she'd grown up impoverished would have hindered that whole "I know I look a lot like her..." angle.

Lisa
Aug 3, 2007 9:45 AM
 
I guess this goes into the catogory of soo bad its good.
Zara
Aug 3, 2007 9:56 AM
 
It's a bad horror movie which in turn made it a really hysterical comedy. Which wasn't its intention. So how does a girl give it stars, ya know?
Lisa
Aug 3, 2007 10:54 AM
 
you gotta rate it on entertainment value, and it seem you where entertained.

I am curious to see this movie, however I think I'll wait for it to hit dvd, I have to get my MAT DAAAMON fix this weekend.
B Movie Ben
Aug 3, 2007 3:36 PM
 
1 for each t*t that you didn't see.

Joe
Aug 4, 2007 2:26 AM
 
Havnt seen it, not gonna see it, but damn, I like a cuddle buddy

dan
Aug 17, 2007 4:15 AM
 
People that don't understand the movie "I know who killed me" here *spoliers* I'll explain it to you.
CobaltDuck explains - The Movie is not about a Twin finding her sister like some psychological mystery crime drama. ITs not really torture porn. Its a Psychological thriller. The movie a about Aubrey using her imagination to try to solve the mystery of who is killing her. Aubrey doesn't make it. Aubrey is killed. Aubrey is captured, tortured, buried alive, and the mysterious killer gets away with it. Aubrey doesn't know who is killing her, so she retreats to her mind and to avoid the pain and try to make sense out of why this is happening to her. That part where Dakota lays down next to Aubrey isn't a tired Dakota taking a quick nap its Aubrey finally dieing.

The MOvie on the very first viewing is suppose to confuse you...it leads you in many directions and possibilities. Only at the end does the movie come into focus.
The 2nd viewing you have the time to look at all the clues and understand why Aubrey is doing this.

People that criticise the movie, including newspaper critics, just don't get the point of the movie. It goes right over their head. The movie isn't suppose to make you feel good. It should make you feel sad/angry/depressed/uncomfortable. It is not a normal happy Holloywood movie. But its tragedy will keep you thinking about it for a long time. the stripper scenes make you feel like the movie you see is real. If the ending was a happy ending the effect would not be the same. Aubrey dies...
I know who killed me is a good movie.
Zara
Aug 17, 2007 10:15 AM
 
Never said that it wasn't good. I feel like I conveyed that it was so bad that it was good. And this explanation feels like one that is thrown out after the fact.

Van Zant wasn't buried wearing a Neil Young t-shirt, but it's kinda cool to think about it.



Subscribe to MatchFlick Movie Reviews through RSS



  RSS | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | About MatchFlick® | Press | Contact Us | FAQs
Partnership and Advertising Opportunities | Movie Database | Merchandise

©2004-2008 MatchFlick®. All rights reserved.
©MOVIE IMAGES ARE COPYRIGHT PROTECTED AND THE PROPERTY OF THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS